Executive Summary

The FSB’s cross-border payments targets have provided an important framework for measuring progress, but global averages can obscure significant differences between corridors and do not always reflect the end-to-end payment experience.

TPA Cross-Border Working Group in collaboration with:

Progress is not always the payment experience

The FSB’s targets established a common framework for improving the cost, speed, access and transparency of cross-border payments. Progress, however, should ultimately be judged by the experience of the end user.

This report finds that global averages can conceal poor outcomes in individual corridors, while improvements to payment infrastructure do not necessarily translate into faster, cheaper or more accessible payments. The framework also leaves security outside the formal target structure despite its growing importance.

Key findings

Cost: Global averages hide expensive corridors

No cost KPI has reached the 1% target, and 18.3% of monitored corridors still exceed the 3% cap. A falling global average can coexist with stagnant costs in the corridors where cost matters most.

Speed: Fast to the bank is not fast to the customer

Around 89% of SWIFT payments reach the recipient's bank within an hour, but only around 60% reach the customer's account in that time. The delay sits in the final leg: compliance checks, batch processing, and operating hours, and the target explicitly carves compliance out. In many cases, predictability is more important than speed.

Access: Having an account is not the same as having access

Progress is tracked through account ownership, which is a precondition for access rather than a measure of it. The unbanked are absent from the KPI. The target is satisfied by a single option, however slow or expensive. It also ignores whether PSPs can access payment systems, which determines whether options exist in the first place.

Transparency: A disclosure checklist is not transparency

The KPI checks only whether cost and speed are disclosed at initiation. Only 62.9% of cost-transparent providers also disclose speed. Status tracking, delays and failures go unmeasured.

Safety: Payment risk is missing from the targets

Faster, cheaper and more accessible payments can also increase exposure to fraud and other risks. Yet the current framework does not explicitly measure safety, making it difficult to assess whether gains in cost, speed and access are being achieved without increasing risk.

What needs to change

The findings point to a need to rethink how progress in cross-border payments is defined and measured. Improving individual parts of the ecosystem is not enough if those improvements do not translate into better outcomes for users. Future efforts should focus more closely on the end-to-end payment journey, recognise differences between corridors, and address dependencies among the four existing target areas of cost, speed, access, and transparency. This report also argues that any successor framework should treat safety as a fifth, explicit outcome.

Measure performance end-to-end and at corridor level

Retain the four existing outcome areas of cost, speed, access and transparency, while increasingly measuring performance across the complete payment journey and at corridor level where appropriate.

Look beyond global averages

Supplement global averages with distributions and corridor-level measures so that significant differences in performance, including persistently high-cost or slow corridors, remain visible.

Measure the outcome experienced by the end user

Assess whether funds reach the intended recipient at the expected cost and speed, with appropriate access and information, rather than relying solely on the performance of individual infrastructures, intermediaries or payment legs.

Account for dependencies and trade-offs

Treat cost, speed, access and transparency as interdependent outcomes. Future measurement should identify where progress in one area affects performance or risk in another, rather than assessing each target entirely in isolation.

Develop an explicit safety and security dimension

Consider incorporating safety and security explicitly into the future framework, with clearly differentiated measures for areas such as payment fraud and misdirection, fund recovery, financial-crime controls, and operational and cyber resilience.

Contents

Previous page

How the framework was designed

Next page